I Tried 3 Sheet Masks, Each Under $4

2018-08-14T12:35:47-05:00August 9th, 2018|Beauty, Style|14 Comments

It was one of those days at Ulta where you go in for one thing and come out with four. I didn’t even get the thing I went in for. But I did grab 3 sheet masks.

Every time the seasons change, my skin freaks out. When I’m outside, it’s oily. After I’m back in the A/C – it’s  dry. So I decided (while staring at the face mask shelf) I need to figure something out. I’ve only ever used 1 mask before and I loved it! It was the Karuna Hydrating + Face Mask (left) from a Fab Fit Fun box, however it costs $8 for one sheet! So I grabbed three different brands, all at $4 or less and decided to give them a shot and share my experience!

This post contains affiliate links with Amazon.com. If you purchase through any of the links below, I will make a small referral commission at no additional cost to you. My opinion of the product is unsolicited and all truly my own. I have not received any free products or payment for my opinion, just the referral commission if you purchase through a link!


Mask 1: TonyMoly, I’m Real:
Pearl Sheet Mask Luminating

Find it on Ulta.com here

Rated 4 Stars on Ulta.com.
What drew me to this sheet mask was that it contains a pearl ingredient that it says will “make skin look clear and glowing”. I also liked the packaging (I’m a designer, so I always shop-by-package). Finally, the price point was great, in my opinion – reg. price $3.75 and it was on “sale” for $3.12.

Initial Thoughts: The mask feels pretty greasy…

The Verdict: When I took this off, my skin felt really greasy. Also, compared to the Karuna, my face doesn’t feel as hydrated. The mask itself dried up before the recommended time was up, and my cheeks stung a bit (they’re pretty sensitive!). Not gonna try this one again. I’ll stick to pearl jewelry.

Mask 2: Pacifica Energized Glow
Turmeric Spice Facial Mask

Find it on Ulta.com here

Rated 4 Stars on Ulta.com
This mask caught my attention because the packaging is colorful, and it has turmeric! As you can tell, I’m drawn to those more interesting ingredients (pearl, turmeric). The price was $4.

Initial Thoughts: The mask has cute heart eye cutouts, and I like the smell! But maybe I have a big head because the sides don’t cover my entire face, but the forehead is too long, and the mouth cutout is too low… also, rip the eye cutouts so they aren’t near your eyes, because the turmeric kinda burns.

The Verdict: This one didn’t dry up! It even had serum leftover at the end to rub on the areas the mask didn’t cover. And my face feel very hydrated!

Ulta Sheet Masks

Mask 3: Smart Skincare Solutions
Skin Energizing Bubbling Sheet Mask  |  Revitalizing Oxygen

Find it on Ulta.com here

Rated 3 Stars on Ulta.com
I was intrigued by the word “bubbling”. I half expected a pop-rocks situation, and the girl at the checkout had great things to say about it. The price was $3.

Initial Thoughts: Trying to unfold this mask was almost impossible! It was sort of slimy and hard to work with. Once it was on, it was really refreshing though. It’s not greasy feeling, and it’s not burning my eyes, so this is potentially my favorite of the three!

The Verdict: I didn’t get that tingling feeling… But this was the only mask that had additional instructions for the end: splash face with warm water after you remove the mask. Followup with moisturizer. – Really, that sealed the deal for me! The rinse and moisturizer really helps. Unlike the other two masks, my face doesn’t feel oily, or tight. It didn’t burn at all, and my skin feels great! I highly recommend this one.


Just a note about my skin, so you can understand my verdicts a little better: my T-Zone is typically oily, my cheeks are dry and sensitive, and most of my breakouts occur on my forehead and jaw line!


Looking for some cute summer outfits to go with your glowing skin? Check out my Summer Wish List!


Pin for later!

Review of 3 Sheet Masks, Each Under $4 | It's Megan Blog | #beauty #beautytips #skincare #selfcare #facemasks


  1. Whitney of WorthyStyle August 20, 2018 at 12:04 pm - Reply

    I love the Pacifica brand – really eco friendly and seems to have lots of variety. Thank you for reviewing these sheet masks – I always love hearing about more beauty products!

  2. Elisha August 20, 2018 at 12:33 pm - Reply

    Great reviews. Thank you! I love to hear how products work on real people. And now I know what to snag on my trip to Ulta this week! 😉

  3. Chelsea August 20, 2018 at 1:49 pm - Reply

    I’ll have to try that Pacifica one, I didn’t even know they had sheet masks!

  4. Fonda @Savvy Southern Chic August 20, 2018 at 5:40 pm - Reply

    I have yet to try sheet masks, but I really enjoyed your reviews!

  5. Amber August 20, 2018 at 9:20 pm - Reply

    I’ll have to add the last two to my wishlist! I love sheet masks!

  6. Marielle August 21, 2018 at 2:48 am - Reply

    I love sheet masks! It feels like having a mini spa day at home. I’ve only tried korean sheet masks so far but I’m interested in the western ones too. Thanks for the review! Won’t mind seeing more of these 😀

  7. Holly August 21, 2018 at 8:00 am - Reply

    I don’t typically use sheet masks very often, but I do want to try that Pacifica one! It sounds like it worked pretty well!

  8. Mary August 21, 2018 at 9:54 am - Reply

    great review of these sheet masks, I’ll have to try them out!

  9. Diana Tidswell August 21, 2018 at 11:05 am - Reply

    I haven’t tried to use a facial mask sheet but these three looks so good and really affordable.

  10. Meghan August 21, 2018 at 11:38 am - Reply

    I love pearl masks! I’m surprised this one didnt live up since the pearl mask at Sephora for me worked wonders!

    • Megan August 21, 2018 at 4:32 pm - Reply

      I’ll have to give that one a try! I had very high hopes!

  11. Cindy Ingalls August 21, 2018 at 10:28 pm - Reply

    Ulta is such a great place for finding sheet masks. I’ve been sucked in so many times, especially while waiting to checkout. I can’t remember the name of the brand, but there are ones that look like animals. So when you wear them you look like a Panda or Tiger. It’s kitsch but does deliver great results.

  12. Rosemary August 22, 2018 at 10:49 pm - Reply

    Have not heard of any of these, but I really like the sound of Pacifica. Always try to use a mask at least once per week, especially in the Summer. Thanks for the recommendations.

  13. Brittany Nicole August 30, 2018 at 11:29 am - Reply

    I’ve tried a few of the Tony Molly masks and I loooove Pacifica as a brand! xo, Brittany Nicole | http://www.theblistblog.com

Leave A Comment